When Photoshop is so good it’s bad

urbanism – landscape – ideas – theory – whimsy

When Photoshop is so good it’s bad

huge-highway_FAKE-I405-Los-Angeles_illusion-web

The monster highway from hell that doesn't actually exist - move over with your mouse to see the reality - original photo by Philip Greenspun

After being sent this image of a monster highway in an email, I became rather obsessed with finding out where on earth this could be and devoted quite some time to searching for any hints about where the widest highways in the world were, but to no avail! Every time I thought I might be onto it, satellite imagery would show the reputed “widest” were rarely even close to this behemoth. Examining the photo closely, I noticed some strange discrepancies that began to make me suspect that it might have been manipulated – there are a couple of groups of vehicles that seem to be repeated, in the distance there are two green highway signs which felt like they might be clones, and something about it felt a little fake, like it was just too good (or maybe that’s bad) to be true.

Finally after some rather more random image searches, I came across the answer: this image is a very good fake based on a photo of Interstate 405 in Los Angeles taken from the Getty Center. First I found some similar views of the I-405 which clearly showed it was only half the width of the fake but the landscape and adjacent buildings matched. The key was the strange shed-like building on the left which is actually the station for the tram that takes people up to the Getty Center from the parking structure beside the highway. Then I managed to find the original photo itself (by a guy called Philip Greenspun, who ironically is rather serious about protecting his photo copyright). The photo was heavily manipulated (apparently without Greenspun’s knowledge) to create this poster-child of Photoshop creativity. Even though the I-405 is one of the busiest highways in America, strangely enough the original photo shows quite light traffic in comparison to the imaginings of the photo manipulator.

While this case might seem rather amusing because the use of image manipulation helps to demonize our highway obsession, the skill with which the image has been manipulated leads to some serious bending of reality and potential (dare I say, deliberate?) misunderstandings. If an image of a highway had been manipulated to make it look like it was less wide than it really was, and that image found its way into a presentation on whether or not to widen that highway, all of a sudden the whole business doesn’t seem so funny and harmless. This is why reputable news agencies are having to take a strong stand against image manipulation by photojournalists, as sometimes, adjusting light levels and contrast isn’t all that they’re up to.

In any case, rest easy Toronto, the 401 can still claim its place as more or less the widest and busiest highway in the world!

Eerily empty Highway 401, Toronto (and no, not as a result of manipulation!) - photo by Kenny Louie

18 Comments so far
Leave a comment

Good detective work Alphonse. I am truly impressed.

Oh wow, my dad actually had me believing that this was real. -______- Thanks for setting the record straight! Oh and yea, great detective work. 🙂

Outstanding sleuthing and analysis!

[…] ist wirklich LA plus Photoshop. Komisch nur, dass es alle Nachrichtenagenturen […]

Agree with H. Pike Oliver. Have you done similar investigations recently. Anything published in the media?

A superb put-down. Has it ben publised anyjwhere apart frp, FB” Are you working on any other photoscams?

Thanks .This is the proof that I needed badly.

Actually it is a real photo. It happened in China and it was 60 miles long and lasted for more then 10 days. Simple Google search China highway 110 traffic jam.

No, apparently you didn’t fully read my post. It is a fake. 100%. The photo is from California, not China. Just because it comes up in a google search doesn’t mean it’s true.

It is kind of an old post but still highly relevant.

I posted it on my site with The Treachery of Images angle. I hope it’s ok.

Thank you

Actually, the traffic jam that david mentioned did happen in China. HOWEVER, the photo itself is a fake.
Many serious and joke websites use unrelated photographs to illustrate the 2010 traffic jam. Many of them were taken from a photoshopped image from Interstate 405 (California), Los Angeles

its amazing if this happened in a developing nation like ours it could have been worse

“Actually it is a real photo. It happened in China and it was 60 miles long and lasted for more then 10 days. Simple Google search China highway 110 traffic jam.” God you just made me laugh so hard… Do the world a favor and never have children!

Sheesh really david? Yes there was a traffic jam in China that lasted several days, NO that is not a picture of it. Capice?

“In any case, rest easy Toronto, the 401 can still claim its place as more or less the widest and busiest highway in the world!”
No, it isn’t…

Thank you so much for solving this mystery! Every time I saw this photo I wondered where it was. Hilarious that it has become an iconic photo for an event that happened in a different continent!

I, too, was obsessed with identifying this freeway when I saw this picture. I eventually found the roadsides on Google Earth, and realized it was photoshopped. Amazing to me was that there are no big rigs in the picture.

I’ve been to China. They wouldn’t stay that neatly in the lanes.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

An ongoing series of reflections on the city, the landscape and the fields that manipulate them from the perspective of urban design, landscape architecture, Toronto and Canada.

Posts RSS
PaD Shanghai Photos RSS
From the Vault Photos RSS

About

Photos

From the Vault (Photos)

PaD Shanghai (Photos)